Skip to Content

7 Best Aji Amarillo Paste Substitute

Aji Amarillo is one of the most commonly used spices in Latin America. It’s a must-have to add that extra kick to your cooking. It provides that bright, citrusy flavor and makes any dish taste great! Unless you have a very sensitive palate, you’re probably going to come across it in almost every dish you eat. 

However, it can be a little bit expensive; so if you don’t have access to it or can’t afford it, then worry not! There are plenty of substitutes for Aji Amarillo paste that will let you keep your kitchen stocked with this exciting ingredient without breaking the bank. Read on for more information about different substitutes for Aji Amarillo and how to go about using them in your cooking.

How To Substitute Aji Amarillo Paste

Aji Amarillo is a bright, citrus-flavored herb. It can be used in a variety of dishes, from curries and salsas to salad dressing and dips. Its distinct flavor is essential to Latin American cuisines. While you can’t really substitute Aji Amarillo with any other herb, you can easily substitute it with other ingredients that have a similar citrusy flavor, like lime, lemon, orange, or grapefruit. 

If you don’t have access to Aji Amarillo, then you can use one of its substitutes. Since not all of them have a citrusy flavor, you can use them to create citrus-flavored dishes that are similar to the original flavor. Here’s how you can substitute Aji Amarillo paste:

  • For aji Amarillo:use cilantro, basil, or other herbs with similar citrusy flavors. 
  • For aji panca: use turmeric or paprika.
  • For aji limo: use allspice or cinnamon. 
  • For aji panca limo: use allspice and turmeric. 
  • For aji pico: use cayenne or paprika. 
  • For aji panca pico: use cayenne and turmeric. 
  • For aji culantro: use culantro or coriander.

Best Aji Amarillo Paste Substitute

1. Sumac paste

Sumac paste
Sumac paste

Sumac is a sour, lemony spice that is widely used in Middle Eastern and Eastern European cuisines. It can be substituted with aji Amarillo paste or cilantro. Sumac is a natural ingredient and is available in powder form. You can use it for marinades, curries, stews, or pita bread stuffing. Sumac paste, on the other hand, is made from dried sumac and contains ash as a binding agent. Though it is not exactly the same as Aji Amarillo, it is used in many similar ways. 

Therefore, if you don’t have access to Aji Amarillo, you can use Sumac paste. Sumac paste is available in grocery stores. It can be used in place of Aji Amarillo in any recipe that calls for it. You can substitute it with cilantro or basil, two herbs with a similar flavor. Both are available in grocery stores, making them a very easy substitute.

2. Turmeric Paste

Turmeric is a root that is used extensively in Indian and Asian cuisines. It can be substituted with paprika or a ground spice such as garam masala. Turmeric is a root that is used as a dye. In India, it is traditionally used in curries and as a seasoning. 

It is available in the form of a paste or as a powder that can be mixed with water and consumed or used in cooking. You can use turmeric paste in place of Aji Amarillo paste or cilantro. 

Though cilantro is a similar herb, it has a stronger flavor, so you can use turmeric paste as a substitute. Turmeric paste is available in grocery stores and is readily available. It can be used in any recipe that calls for Aji Amarillo. You can make your own turmeric paste by grinding a tablespoon of turmeric with a little bit of water. You can store the paste in an airtight jar for a long time. You can use it for 6 months.

3. Paprika

Paprika is a spice that is used in many European and Asian cuisines. It can be substituted with garam masala, a ground spice mixture that is used in Indian, Pakistani, and South Asian food. Paprika is a dried, red pepper that is used in many dishes. 

It is available in powdered form and can be used as a substitute for aji Amarillo. You can use paprika in many recipes, such as in potato salad, pasta dishes, or in vegetables like carrots, parsnips, or beets. You can also use it in pickled vegetables, such as gherkins, or in chutneys. You can find paprika in grocery stores or online. 

It is relatively inexpensive, and it can last for a very long time. There is no need to buy new paprika as long as you store the old one properly. You can use paprika in any recipe that calls for aji Amarillo.

4. Carrot Powder

Aji Amarillo is a citrus-flavored herb. It can be substituted with carrot powder. Aji Amarillo is used in many Asian and Latin American dishes. It is available in the form of a paste or as a powder. You can use carrot powder in many dishes with a strong Asian or Latin American flavor. 

It is used in carrot cake, carrot soup, carrot juice, carrot muffins, etc. Carrot Powder is available at most grocery stores and can be used in place of aji Amarillo. It can also be used as a substitute in many other dishes like carrot cake, carrot juice, and carrot muffins. 

You can use carrot powder to create dishes that have a strong Asian or Latin American flavor.

5. Lime Powder

Lime powder substitute
Lime powder substitute

Aji Amarillo is a citrus-flavored herb that can be substituted with lime powder. It is widely used in Asian and Latin American cuisines. Aji Amarillo can be used in place of lime powder. 

Lime powder is available in grocery stores and can be used in many dishes that don’t have a strong citrus flavor. You can find the lime powder at most grocery stores and can use it in many dishes that don’t have a strong citrus flavor. 

It can be used in soups, salads, or in seafood dishes. You can substitute aji Amarillo with lime powder and add a fresh citrus flavor to a variety of dishes.

6. Onion Paste

Onion paste substitute
Onion paste substitute

Aji Amarillo is a citrus-flavored herb that can be substituted with an onion paste. It is widely used in Asian and Latin American cuisines. Aji Amarillo can be substituted with an onion paste. Onion paste is available in the form of a dehydrated powder and can be used in many dishes that don’t have a strong onion flavor. 

Onion paste is available at most grocery stores and can be used in many dishes that don’t have a strong onion flavor. You can use it in curries, in stews, or in pasta dishes. You can also use it in pickles and chutneys. Aji Amarillo can be substituted with an onion paste and add a fresh onion flavor to many dishes.

7. Habanero Peppers

Habanero Peppers
Habanero Peppers

Alternatively, habanero peppers are an excellent choice.

They pack a serious heat but balance it out with a pleasant fruitiness that works well in a wide variety of foods.

It’s important to remember to take the time to remove the seeds from the habanero pepper before you add it to your recipe.

Also, these peppers are so hot that you must wear rubber gloves whenever you handle them. Since inhaling the fumes from these peppers might be irritating, it is recommended that you use a mask if one is available.

Peppers of the habanero kind are frequently used in spicy sauce, but you can also buy them fresh at some markets and specialized stores.

However, they tend to be rather pricey and are often only accessible throughout the summer.

Conclusion

Aji Amarillo is a popular herb in Latin American cuisine. It can be substituted with cilantro, basil, or other herbs with a citrusy flavor. Sumac can be substituted with paprika or turmeric, and paprika can be substituted with garam masala. 

A carrot powder can be used in place of aji Amarillo, Lime powder can be substituted with lime, or can be used in place of vinegar or salt.

More Substitutes: