Skip to Content

7 Best Butcher Paper Substitutes

Attention, clever cooks! Wrap your smoked meat in butcher paper for extra tenderness and moisture.

Once you give this simple method for making delicious smoked meat a try, you won’t be able to stop making it.

I consider butcher paper to be a necessity because of all the different ways it can be put to good use around the house. Use it for DIY projects, food preservation, or even t-shirt printing!

But if you are in a rush and don’t have any butcher paper on hand, you can still smoke the ideal pork roast right this second.

Parchment paper is an attractive substitute for butcher paper. It’s a healthy option that mimics the pore structure of butcher paper in that it’s permeable. If you don’t have any butcher paper on hand, you may use a paper bag instead. For sublimation purposes, Kraft paper can be used instead of butcher paper.

Best Butcher Paper Substitutes

1. Parchment paper 

Parchment paper is an excellent choice to use in the place of butcher paper.

Because of its inexpensive price and the ease with which it may be utilized, it has actually become a more popular option than butcher paper.

Because it does not require any further preparation or tools, putting it to use is a very straightforward process.

The adaptability of parchment paper is one of its most notable qualities.

Because it is both thin and flexible, it may be used in place of butcher paper to wrap food items such as sushi rolls and sandwiches. This makes it an excellent alternative to butcher paper.

In addition, you may use parchment paper to line baking sheets or frying pans. Both of these uses are possible with this versatile material.

You don’t need to worry about using this in the microwave or on the cooktop because it can withstand high temperatures in the oven.

The fact that parchment paper comes in a variety of colors means that you may select the shade that corresponds most closely to the requirements that you have.

2. Aluminum Foil

It makes perfect sense to put aluminum foil at the very top of this list.

When wrapping food for cooking, baking, freezing, or reheating, aluminum foil is a very useful material to have on hand.

It is also possible to keep it among conventional foods such as cereal or chips.

Aluminum foil is flexible and resilient.

This makes it simple to fold food into tightly packed storage containers as well as simple to store away leftovers in their respective containers.

In addition to this, aluminum foil is very resistant to tearing and ripping.

You may use it repeatedly without having to worry about having to replace it in a short amount of time.

Aluminum foil is a common item found in kitchens everywhere due to its long shelf life and versatility.

Because it is, in almost every circumstance, superior to butcher paper, you won’t have many occasions on which to make use of this wrap.

3. Wax Paper 

Butcher paper can also be replaced with wax paper, which is another excellent alternative.

It is also quite reasonably priced, which makes it an appealing alternative for people who are operating under a financial constraint or who need to replenish their supply on a regular basis.

However, wax paper is notoriously difficult to slice through.

Before beginning the cutting process, it is necessary to arrange it on a flat work surface.

When doing so, you should also make use of a box cutter or knife that is in good condition.

Why? When using dull blades, the wax paper can easily be torn or ripped.

Wax paper is typically white in color, and it has blue lines running across it at regular intervals. In terms of its overall design and look.

You may also have it in brown if you want to go for a design that is more in line with nature.

Wax paper has a low density and a low thickness, making it a good substitute for butcher paper.

4. Kitchen Towels 

Instead of butcher paper, you can use a kitchen towel.

They are not as widely available as parchment paper, yet they perform just as well in the kitchen.

Towels from the kitchen are handy for many things, including wrapping presents, scrubbing the oven, and drying bread.

Use a clean kitchen towel to wrap a baked good like a pie or cake as a present, then secure the package with a twist and a bow (if necessary).

Towels for the kitchen come in handy in many ways, including covering dishes before placing them in the oven.

When shopping for kitchen towels, it’s important to think about factors like absorbency, durability, and ease of cleaning.

If you want to know which side of your towel is best for soaking up liquids, look for a directional pattern.

Towels that can stretch and hold their shape will serve you well when cleaning.

Using thin kitchen towels might cause them to rip after a while.

In addition, since you’ll be staring at your towel all day, it should have a design that appeals to your sense of style.

5. Baking Mats 

In recent times, an increasing number of individuals have become aware of the benefits that baking mats may provide. They are excellent for keeping food from adhering to baking sheets, and they are also able to endure the varying temperatures that might occur in an oven. However, the fact that these materials allow air to pass through them makes them suitable for smoking meat. 

By encasing a beef cut of moderate size in a baking mat, you can ensure that it takes on an adequate amount of smokey flavor without suffering significant loss of moisture.

Baking mats, on the other hand, maybe rather pricey, and most households do not even have a single one. If you don’t like the texture, though, it makes for a great substitute for butcher paper. 

Also, keep in mind that it may not be possible to completely wrap some of the more substantial chunks of meat. Therefore, you might need to engage two people in such circumstances.

6. Paper Bags 

Paper bags are a typical method for transporting food, which is why you may find them in both quick-service restaurants and grocery shops. Because of their sufficient thickness, they are also an acceptable alternative to butcher paper in emergency situations. 

Paper bags are not as durable as any of the other available options; yet, they are an excellent choice for low-heat, expedient smoking settings. In addition, as long as you apply indirect heat to them, they will function without a hitch.

However, you should be aware that not all paper bags may be used for the safe handling of food. As a result, you should be sure to confirm that the one you’ve chosen is approved by the FDA.

Additionally, paper bags should only be used for smoking recipes that won’t last for a lengthy amount of time. It may catch fire if it is subjected to an excessive amount of heat, even if it is just moderate.

7. Plastic Wrap

When it comes to freezing food, plastic wrap is a fantastic alternative to butcher paper. It prevents meals from getting freezer burned by adhering securely to them. In addition to this, you should have no trouble locating it in any supermarket you visit.

The substance known as polyvinyl chloride, which is a chemical compound, is used to make a plastic wrap. It’s possible that some individuals won’t enjoy how artificial it seems in comparison to butcher paper.

Despite this, it is widely acknowledged as a substance that is safe for consumption and is utilized by a large number of individuals all over the world.